top of page

Flavor Combinations

Coconut Milk Cake with choice of Lilikoi Buttercream or White Chocolate Macadamia

 with Mac Nuts​ or Pina Colada Buttercream

Guava Cake with POG Frosting

Queen Emma: Sandwiched Layers of Coconut, Lilikoi, & Guava with matching Buttercream filling (only available for cakes) 6 layers- $20 up charge.

Pineapple Cake with choice of Pineapple, Coconut, Pina Colada buttercream, 

or Cream Cheese Frosting

Lemon Blueberry Cake with choice of Lemon, Lavender, or Cream Cheese Frosting

Chocolate Cake with choice of Oreo, Chocolate, Espresso, Peanut Butter, White Chocolate,

Vanilla, or White Chocolate Macadamia Buttercream

Red Velvet Cake with choice of Vanilla, Oreo, Chocolate, or Cream Cheese Frosting

Funfetti Cake with Birthday Buttercream

Vanilla Cake with choice of Vanilla, Almond, Birthday, 

Chocolate, Coconut, Oreo, Lilikoi, White Chocolate, or White Chocolate Macadamia

Pink Champagne Cake with Sparkling Wine Buttercream 

Australian freeze dried Blueberry, Strawberry, or Raspberry with Matching Buttercream

Almond Cake with choice of Vanilla, Almond, or Coconut Buttercream 

*We don't use whip cream, fruit compotes, mousse, or wet fillings due to their slippery nature and the heat and humidity on Maui to protect the integrity of the cake.

If you want fresh fruit as decorations such as strawberries, blackberries, blueberries or raspberries there is an up-charge of $10 per fruit.

 

**Gluten Free is available upon request for an additional fee**

 

CAKE SIZES AND STARTING PRICES

 

The average cake is 4 layers high. If you want a smaller cake check the Bento Box section.

Below is a starting price and average amount of servings. The number is party cut

like a pie. If you cater cut each slice in half you will get more servings.

NOTE: These are base starting prices and anything additional e.g. toppers, accents,

detailed piping, flowers, will be an additional fee. If you want delivery we will

quote you based on your location from Wailuku.

Please send ALL the information on the How to order page for a quote.

Check IG or FB for more photos.

Starting Prices

As a Single Tier Naked or Plain Buttercream

 5" cake feeds 8       $130

 6" cake feeds 12     $150

 7” cake feeds 14    $170

 8" cake feeds 16     $190

 9" cake feeds 18     $210

 10” cake feeds 20    $230

For larger Weddings and Events you can add on sheet cakes. These are back of

house extra cakes for guests and aren't custom designed.

1/4 Sheet 2 layer with basic piping feeds 15      $75

  1/2 Sheet 2 layer with basic piping feeds 25      $150

 

For basic tiered cakes, pick your size combination add on $25 stacking and assembling fee. Flowers, toppers, and accents are additional and priced accordingly. 

Common sizes and starting base prices are: 

5'&7" $325

6"& 8" $365 

PLEASE READ!!!

**Upon ordering please specify colors, style, aesthetics, flowers, acrylic toppers or charms, fondant accents, etc which are all additional. You are welcome to order your own topper and it is advised to ship it directly to us so we can assemble and finish the cake before delivery. We have someone on island that makes our custom acrylic toppers. We work with

TLC Laser Works for all custom acrylic designs.

Please Text a photo for inspiration for a quote. Please note it's an inspiration. Cakes will not be copied exactly from someone else's work nor will they be exactly the same as my previous cakes. Cakes are subject to our style and not the style of other cake designers. Cakes are subject to creative freedom during designing and some aspects aren't always available that were once used before. Specific flowers aren't promised as some are

seasonal and availability always changes.

Flavors don't always affect the color of the outside of the cake and are for the inside filling. Most cakes are finished on the outside in our Swiss vanilla buttercream and can be in any color of choice unless specified.

PLEASE NOTE: We are a Food Permitted home kitchen. Cakes, and desserts may contain

traces of nuts, gluten, dairy, seeds Etc. We are not responsible for allergies of you or your guests.

CAKE CARE AND HANDLING

 

Delivery is optimum and suggested.
Pick up for free is available in Wailuku at Foodland by Coffee Bean
For specific quotes please send the address.
These are general quotes for single tiers and cupcakes.
Tiered cakes and dessert tables are priced accordingly.
Wailuku~Kahului $10-$15
 Kihei~Wailea~Makena $25-$55
Olowalu~Lahaina~Kaanapali $45-$60
Napili~Kahana-Kapalua $65-$75
Paia~Haiku $30-$60
Pukalani~Makawao~Kula $30-$55

If you decide to meet and pick up your order we suggest you do a few things to prepare.

 

~Make sure there’s adequate fridge space. Most cakes are 5”-12” high and on a cake board 8-12“ round depending on the cake size. Cupcake boxes are generally 14”x10”. This entails sometimes taking a shelf out of the fridge.

 

~For transporting please have the AC on, go straight to your location that has appropriate fridge space, and keep the passenger floor clear for the cake to travel on. It’s the safest place in the car. Make sure the seat has no objects that can fall on the cake. Do not hold the cake.
Please do not go shopping and leave the cake in the hot car.
Maui is a hot and humid tropical island and your cake will melt. 

 

~Keep the cake refrigerated until a minimum of 15 min before serving. If you're keeping a cake out longer please make sure the room temperature is 73 degrees or cooler. Do not put the cake in direct sunlight or leave outside longer than
15 min.

 

~If a cake is being delivered please have it come within an hour of eating or have adequate space in your refrigerator.  
~If your traveling to Maui please check with your hotel/condo about the refrigerator size. If your having a cake delivered to a restaurant please call to make sure they take outside food. Ask them to put the details in your reservation and ask about their cutting/plating fee.

 

~2-tier cakes are NOT allowed to be picked up. Delivery ONLY! 

 

~For beach parties delivery it is highly suggested to have delivery within
15 min of eating. 

 

If you choose to pick up, the Frosted Mermaid is not responsible for your cakes and desserts melting or being damaged after leaving our presence. You then take full responsibility for your order! After Delivery we are not responsible for your handling and improper cake care.
cake galley
bottom of page